HAMAN, HITLER, HATE

As I swung my grogger (noise maker) on Purim, just two weeks ago, I was symbolically blotting out the name of Haman.  I tried to include the name Hitler in my symbolic act as well.

Haman was the prime minister of the Persian Empire in the fifth century before the common era.  He was second only to the King – Ahasuerus.  Haman’s goal was to murder all the Jews living within Persian-controlled lands and to take all their money.   His plan was thwarted by Queen Esther, a Jewish woman, who stood up for her people and saved them.  We still celebrate Esther as a savior some 2,400 years later.

In the 20th century of the Common Era, there was another, more successful Haman.  His name was Adolf Hitler.   Hitler succeeded in murdering six million Jews, including 90% of all Polish Jewry.

The Queen’s namesake, Esther Bryndl Wisznia Goldberg did what she could to thwart Hitler’s evil decree.  She could not save all her people, but she saved Chaim Kwaitek, Velvel Schneidman, Sam Goldberg and herself.   Together, she and Sam brought new life into the world.  Now three more generations of Jews are twirling their groggers on Purim.

Sam and Esther’s survival is not what Hitler wanted.  He and his Nazi regime worked hard to have a different outcome.  Out of three million Polish Jews, approximately 300,000 (10%) were alive at the end of the war.  Of the 250,000 Polish Jews who hid in the woods or in constructed bunkers in Poland, only 50,000 made it.[1]

Jews hiding in Poland had the deck stacked against them.  Where could they hide? What could they eat? How would they survive the freezing winters and the blistering summers?  But on top of these challenges, the Germans created incentives for the local Polish population to root out the hidden Jews.  Rewards were offered:  cash; sugar; vodka; share of the Jews’ valuables or clothing.  In case further encouragement was needed (which often it was not), the Nazis forced Polish village elders to nominate someone each week.  If a Jew was found in the vicinity of the village, the nominated person would be killed.  This added to the incentive to head out on a “Jew-hunt.”

Jan Gross, the Polish- American historian (whose writings are discussed in blog post October 19, 2016 & Dec. 4, 2016) explains that as a result of “established stereotypes and the cruel environment created by the Germans, hunting and exploiting Jews was ‘socially acceptable.’ Extortion, torture, rape and murder were not activities on the fringe of society, conducted by marginal elements, but ‘an acceptable social practice.’ Village elders, mayors, police officers, firemen, forest rangers and upstanding citizens all took part in Jew-hunts and sought to profit from the mythical wealth of the Jews.”[2]

Jews in hiding did not make it without help.[3]  Esther survived hiding in the Polish woods for two years and Sam for one.  Sam’s year in the woods was after his survival of 13 months at Treblinka – a 0.0069 % survival rate.  For Sam and Esther, help came from the Stys families (many blog posts about them).  I am excited to report that my daughter, Esther (yes, named for the Esther of this blog) and I will be visiting the Stys families in a month.  It will be, yet again, an honor to stand in their presence and spend time with them.

But, back to Haman – Isn’t it interesting that the words Haman, Hitler and Hate – all start with the same letter?

Yemach Shemam – May their names be blotted out!

  • The featured picture of a mask because on Purim, we wear costumes, often including a mask.

[1] Cesarani, David, Final Solution: The Fate of the Jews 1933-1949. New York, NY.  St. Martin’s Press. 2016, citing Jan Grbowski, a Polish, Canadian historian at 644.

[2] Final Solution at 647.

[3] Id. at 644.

[4] For another blog post referring to Haman, see Aug. 25, 2016.

Advertisements

1 thought on “HAMAN, HITLER, HATE”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s